If there was one unofficial theme for subscription boxes this month, I think it would be ‘OOPS’. In my Boxyluxe they forgot to include the NARS lip Pigment and in the IPSY Ultimate, they gave me seven ful sized samples instead of eight. They realized this before I actually got my package though and sent me an e-mail explaining they were sending me an extra full sized Serum from 111Skin to make up for their mistake. Even so, it was kind of an OOPS month for everyone.
But let’s start from the beginning shall we? IPSY Glam Bag Ultimate is a $50 per month subscription tier of the IPSY Beauty bag. In it you are supposed to get twelve products, eight full sized and four deluxe sample sized products. This month they were celebrating their 100th glam bag so as an extra they decided to add one more sample size to the bag. So I should have received eight full sized and five sample sized products in my March bag.
Let’s see what I did get.
First up was the BENEFIT COSMETICS Brow Contour Pro in Brown Light (retail $34). This was my first full sized product and I was very happy to receive it. I love Benefit’s brow products. For the longest time I used their Ka-Brow and it was fantastic. I love that this pencil has multiple shades in the same pencil so that I can mix things up to find exactly the right combo for me. I am looking forward to playing around with this.
MANNA KADAR COSMETICS Blush in Bali Babe was my first sample. It is a nice color, but I’ve always found their blushes a bit hard to blend on the cheeks and always end up seeing exactly where the brush touched me face for the first time, so I will probably use it as an eyeshadow more than a blush. It is a great pop of mauve on the lids. It is oddly long lasting as a shadow.
My next sample sized product was the GO-TO Face Hero face oil. I actually received a full size of this from IPSY sometime last year. I think it was in the spring if I am not mistaken. When I looked through my notes I remembered it. I had it marked down as a little too heavy unless I was having a really dry skin day and that it was best used at night rather than during the day. I’ll still try it out again because those notes were from before I started doing reviews so they are sketchy. I did mark down that it was not a product I wanted to repurchase. Still I have it now so I will do an official test and report back. Perhaps my feelings have changed.
The DERMADELI Nourishing Eye Serum was the next sample size in my bag. I have never heard of the brand but I am always up for an eye serum. Currently I am testing the Algenist Eye Cream so I will set it aside to try when my trial of that is complete. I will say the sample seemed a bit small and looked only about half full which was disappointing. With eye serum a little goes a long way, but still it felt a little chintzy.
Moving on to my next sample I received a HEY HONEY Show Your Glow Colloidal Gold & Honey Beauty Mask. I have really liked all of HEY HONEY’s skin care products and I haven’t tried this one so I am happy to have it in the mix. I should probably say that while I love their skin care, I really haven’t liked any of their makeup products that I’ve tried. Its one of those companies that does skin care well, but other things not so much. Still this was skin care, so I’m happy to get something from their strong suit.
Finally another full sized product appeared. It was the THRIVE CAUSEMETICS Lip Mate High-Shine Reviving Topper™ in Ashley (retail $24). I absolutely adore THRIVE’s mascara so I am pleased to try out something else from the brand. In case you are wondering why there is no picture of a swatch, the shade ASHLEY is a clear gloss. I’m not a huge fan of clear gloss but I do like to keep one or two around. I just finished one and as the clear Fenty gloss I received from Boxycharm is very glitter-tastic, this could be a nice addition to my collection.
Next up is a product that just makes me shake my head. It is the 111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Sheet Mask & Celestial Black Diamond Eye Mask Set. It is one mask and one set of under eye patches. It is a full sized product and in case that wasn’t enough to puzzle over this single sheet mask and under eye set retails for $47. That was not a typo. One mask with under eye patches, $47. I will say I had another mask lined up this week because I like to bounce between sheet masks and regular face masks, but the curiosity is a bit too much. I may have to try the $47 sheet mask this week just to see it in action. Don’t worry, I will make a fuss over it too. I will put out my best candles and focus on enjoying it. Because I can guarantee, unless it shaves twenty years and possibly twenty pounds to boot from my body, I am not spending $47 on a single sheet mask. But I will try it to see how good it is. And if there was ever a time for a stress reducing facial treatment to shine, this is it.
The product I chose for this month’s bag was the SUNDAY RILEY C.E.O. 15% Vitamin C Brightening Serum (retail $42.50). It is full sized technically. On the bottle it is listed as being a size specifically designed for IPSY rather than the full size they typically sell, but I can live with that. Partially because I adore Sunday Riley products. I loved the face cream of this line so much I bought a replacement once mine was empty. It is currently unopened as I’ve been testing other face creams. At the moment I am finishing up a face cream trial on a Pacifica moisturizer and once it is complete (next week) I will be working on finishing out all of my open jars before I start another one. I am also trying to finish out two open serums so I won’t be opening this for a while either. I think what I may do is pair it with the Vitamin C moisturizer and see what other products are in the line and maybe do a full regime review of the line. I’ll need to do a bit of research first, but it is a possibility. Either way I love the brightening effect of Vitamin C products on my skin.
While I love skin care products I was very happy to see a second makeup product to go with my Benefit eyebrow pencil and that was the CHELLA La Vie Eyeshadow Palette Deluxe (retail $45). It is a neutral palette and I have tried them on. Next week I will be catching up on my eyeshadow palette reviews and posting several, this one included. I do like the shades and I like the physical palette itself. I think it is a great quick palette to use. With four shades there isn’t much deliberation. I will say I have a hard time thinking of four shadows as a full sized palette though, especially when their description calls it a convenient size for on the go. To me that says travel sized, not full sized.
Interestingly enough I received the CHRISTOPHE ROBIN Cleansing Purifying Scrub with Sea Salt. It is a sample size but I was very happy to receive a hair product from IPSY that is not a leave in conditioner. I have a lot of leave in conditioners I am working through at this point. A hair care item that is different is very appealing. I am looking forward to trying out this hair/scalp scrub.
Despite saying I only rarely want hand creams and body lotions I received not one, but two in this month’s bag. One was full sized the other sample. The LIBRARY OF FLOWERS Honeycomb Hand crème was the full sized (retail $20). It is a beautiful packaging and I adore the scent of honeycomb. I’ve tried their hand cream before and loved it. As I am currently working on several hand creams at the moment, I left this one sealed for later use. The sample sized body lotion was from HEMPZ and it was the Herbal Body Moisturizer in Sweet Pineapple & Honey Melon. There was no internal seal on the bottle so I decided to go ahead and use it for my post shower body lotion. It does make my skin very soft. It also makes me smell like a tropical fruit salad that is a little heavy on the mango. I’m not entirely certain I care for the scent too much but it is good lotion and the small size means I will very quickly use it up.
Finally the last item in my bag was the COMPLEX CULTURE Angled Foundation Brush (retail $35). It is a good brush with soft yet dense bristles and I am sure I will get a lot of use out of it.
As much as I joke about some of the prices and sizes, I actually did enjoy my bag this month. The makeup bag it came with was a bit 80s retro with bright teal and yellow and its rows of metal grommets, but it is a decent bag. I’ve actually seen the sneak peaks for next month’s bag and I find it much more up my alley, but this is a decent bag. It will probably end up passed along to someone else though.
My seven full sized products totaled a value of $247.50, which is an okay return on my $50 buy in. I would have expected a little bit more given the celebratory nature of this month but that could in part be due to the OOPS of the missed full size. I’ll have to see what the extra sent product adds in value when it arrives. I’m sure the sample sizes have value but I’m not entirely sure how to accurately calculate that. Either way I am actually pleased with this month’s bag. It was certainly better than last months and to be honest it was better than this month’s Boxyluxe. Fingers crossed that next month is a good one as well.
Posted below are a few current deals you may want to take advantage of, enjoy!
The more you buy at Laura Geller the better the gift. Every order gets a free gift. Orders of $50+ get Towelettes. Orders of $75+ get Bronzer with Towelettes. Orders of $100+ get an Illuminator with Bronzer and Towelettes. Offer valid though 3/19.