I’ll be honest, most of my thoughts involving toner include things like ‘I really need to pick up some reusable cotton rounds instead of using the disposable ones’ or ‘I don’t like the scent of this toner.’ And of course there is the, ‘wow my makeup remover really left a lot behind if that is what’s coming off on the toner cotton round.’
It is the skin care product that in the past I have not given a lot of thought to. Which is strange really when I think about it. There have been times where I have skipped moisturizer or serums, but I never skip toner. I have been washing my face and then using toner since middle school. Admittedly then it was mostly an acne fighting toner, but it still counts.
Perhaps it is that I now have more acne from wearing a mask in the heat than I have had since my teen years that has caused me to think about this. Either way, think about this I have and I am starting to pay more attention to toners.
Now for those of you wondering why bother with toners at all, I was always taught that they remove the last traces of the day from your face. They take away whatever dirt, excess oils or even any residue left behind by your face wash. It is essentially the tag team partner for the face wash. When used in the morning it gives you a clean canvas for whatever you put on during the day and at night it takes everything off so that you can sleep without whatever life put on your face sinking in over night. (or clear the path for your night time products). Then of course there are the ingredients included in the mix that are supposed to do something other than just take off the day. Each product is different.
According to the product page for the Akar Balance Toning mist…
Deemed as the “Holy Water” by Allure, spray your way to glowing, healthy skin. This non-sticky Rose and Neroli scented mist sets gently into the skin, providing deep hydration, improving overall elasticity, while simultaneously keeping the pH value of the skin’s acid mantle layer at the optimum level. Salicylic acid from White Willow Bark is both anti-microbial and exfoliating, helping prevent build-up in pores as well as acne-related issues. Stem cell extracts from the rare Saffron flower contain antioxidants and carotenoids which aids the epidermis in repair and regeneration. Last but not least, Balance enables greater absorption of nutrients by lowering the skin’s surface tension, which means that all the good stuff – in this toner, and everything you apply next – will be fully absorbed, right into your skin.
That seems like a lot for this toner and to be honest, I am not entirely certain how to actually test many of those claims. But let’s go through what I am capable of testing at home.
First of all, it is a spray. To be honest, I’m not a huge fan of spray toners. I’ve used them before, but it isn’t my preferred method. I really do prefer that I dispense it onto the cotton round and then apply it to my face rather than spritzing my face first and then wiping it around. I will say that it is a very fine mist and sprays out nicely. And the spray is not a deal breaker.
The rose and neroli scent was interesting. For me I think it was a little odd mostly because I tend to like perfumes with neroli in them. It is a scent that I like. (For those not familiar with it, the scent is slightly orang-y – like the fruit not the color – but not overly sweet, more of a tart orange). It does blend well with the rose and it is a lovely scent. However combined with the spray application it made me feel as though I was spraying perfume on my face. I knew I wasn’t, but it sort of felt like I was.
Also, it is a sticky spray. Not oh my goodness I’m coated in honey sticky but tacky to the touch. I didn’t mind this all that much, especially since the description listed it. It was relatively easy to get used to thought.
But it is really all about the effect on the skin. Now I have been getting more break outs recently. I did find that with this spray, the blemishes that erupted weren’t as red and painful and tended to heal more quickly with less scarring. With the exception of the places where the mask connected to my face (where I tend to get an outline of clogged pores if I wear it in the heat) I did notice I had less clogged pores appearing on my face as I used this toner.
To be honest, it was a very good toner. My skin did like it and it did really keep the irritation down on my break outs. Personally I’m attributing that to the willow bark. And despite my early qualms I did enjoy using it.
Would I enjoy using it again? Absolutely.
Do I think that it works so much better than my regular toners that I would be willing to pay the $55 price tag on a regular basis? No. I do not.
I understand that some of the ingredients, like saffron are quite expensive. I have a family recipe that calls for saffron that I make once a year and I am always stunned by its price when I have to buy it. So I understand why this toner is so expensive. My regular toners are between $5 and $10 (generally speaking Thayers and Pixi products). Occasionally I will splurge and try out a toner in a higher price range, there are several that I really do like that are higher priced. However, for me to pay $55 for a toner on a regular basis, it has to be a lot better than my standard toners. While I am willing to admit that it is a bit better than my other toners, it is not far enough above them in function to justify the price.
Will I keep this on my list of products to look out for if there is a skin care sale? Absolutely. If there is a sale that knocks $10-$15 off the price I would scoop this up in a heartbeat. I would then use every drop. It is a great product. It is just slightly over priced for what I feel I get out of it.
Would I feel differently if it weren’t a spray? I don’t believe so. I really think that it comes down to a benefits versus price scale. Truthfully if it were $15 less I would be willing to forget about the spray (and slightly perfume-y scent) and purchase this anyway. Perhaps if I did buy a full sized and saw benefits over a longer period of time, I would feel differently. This sample sized toner spray that came in my August Allure Box lasted two weeks. It contained 1.5 mL worth of product. The full size is 70 mL. So there is the full size would last a little over a year and a half.
There is something to be said for that, however the little expiration jar on the back of the sample sized Akar bottle claims the product expires in 6 months. I don’t know if the larger bottle has the same expiration date. If it does, I don’t know if I could use the product completely before it became expired. I think I would have to look into that before making a purchase. If it didn’t expire in under 12 to 18 months than I could almost see the price being justified.
While my thrifty soul will still be holding out for a sale, I will be looking into the expiration date as well. Meanwhile it was a lovely glass bottle that I enjoyed seeing in my skin care line up and enjoyed using. I was glad it came in my subscription box and I am now adding it to my empties bin. Perhaps it will return, perhaps it won’t, but it was a very good product to receive in my Allure Beauty box.